Hacker and FreeSoftware activist.

Founder of the FreeSoftwareFoundation, creator of the GnuGeneralPublicLicense and wrote much of the modern version of the Emacs editor.

Quora Answer : Why is Richard Stallman more important than Elon Musk?

Dec 15

Richard Stallman is the man who saw, long before most people, the danger that a world eaten by software would be to our rights and freedoms.

If everything you can do in a wired technological society is constrained by software. And software is a black-box controlled by self-interested corporations, who are backed up by draconian intellectual property laws. Then your freedom has effectively gone. You can act only in so far as the software lets you. And the software is hard-coded tyranny.

Most people are just starting to wake up, now, in the 2020s, to the risks of handing control over too much of their lives to big tech. They see what Facebook knows about them. They look across at what China is doing with social credit. And they shudder. But have no idea what to do about it.

But Stallman could see those problems coming in the early 1980s, and was already trying to organize resistance to them, and to redirect the future in a better, healthier and free-er direction.

Stallman wasn't just thinking about programmers. He has stories from the 80s and 90s warning how, say, DRM would make lending books to friends, impossible. (Which is exactly what happened with e-books. People don't lend books to their friends, and the second hand book market is effectively non-existent).

Stallman was thinking about all the ways that those who control the software control our lives, from long, long before it was fashionable.

And he tried his hardest to change the future away from that.

He had a plan :

Politically aware programmers, with a sense of moral purpose, would write software that was deliberately free, whose source-code was open for anyone to read, study, learn from and change, so that users wouldn't be controlled by it. Users would know what their software was doing. And if they didn't like it, could change it to something they did like. Software enabled tyranny would be avoided because ownership of and control of software would be out there in public. Not controlled by corporations or governments.

It was a bold and visionary plan. In many ways before its time. Too few people understood it.

(And it didn't help, that in the 90s, Eric Raymond and Tim O'Reilly came along to sabotage it by claiming that free-software was really just about good business sense and hacker culture, man. And not about morality and the struggle for freedom, at all.)

Of course Stallman comes across as having bee in his bonnet. And most people, unfortunately, ignore him. That's because he's the genuine article. A bona-fide moral visionary. One of the few of our times.

Elon Musk is a bit of an arse. Yes, he's doing good work helping to shift the world to electric cars. That's a "good thing (tm)" and I won't take that away from him. He's also, kind of a "visionary" for putting his money where his mouth is, and doing his bit to push space exploration and Mars colonization. Although I think it's too early for that and he isn't going to succeed. (It's also a "vision" that's remarkably 1950s retro. But sure, give Musk some credit for that.)

But Stallman's GPL should be up there with the Magna Carta and the American Constitution, as another major milestone in legal history and the struggle to protect and guarantee human freedom. It's the only interesting and possibly viable response to the dangers we currently face from a future of ubiquitous computing and networking.

The are only two alternatives in our future. Either our devices are open, and we control them and get them to do what we want because we can program them. Or our devices are closed and controlled by other people, and those other people control us through our devices. (And good luck "opting out" of using devices and ubiquitous social media services if you want to stay a functioning member of society.)

Stallman pretty much saw this 40 years ago. And has been fighting to bring us the first alternative ever since. He's spent his life talking about the dangers, talking about the solutions, and encouraging programmers to join the moral and political movement in favour of defending human freedom from technological tyranny.

That makes him one of the most important political and moral leaders of our times. And possibly of any times in human history.

See also :

Phil Jones (He / Him)'s answer to Will the Free Software Foundation become irrelevant if Clang makes GCC obsolete?


Me on Twitter https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1355518981214523392.html replying to GrahamLally


@6loss

I think Stallman's politics is left and libertarian (where libertarian is "extreme liberal"). The intuition most of us had originally is that with enough freedom, the good drives out the bad. As you know, I think we might be discovering that that is "wrong" in some sense ... \1

But it's still a viable and attractive intuition.

And, yes, the GPL etc. is built on that. So freedom is more important than trying to constrain people to do good. \2

Furthermore ... pragmatically, this appeal to pure freedom clearly engages and recruits more people than if Stallman had tried to use GPL to enforce his own wider political views. You have "right-libertarians" (ESR, or Lessig) on-board with GPL. \3

Finally, I think there is a question whether you could legally codify and enforce restrictions on use. GPL is all about hacking existing copyright law and its definition of "derivative". Because derivation is a well established legal idea, that bit is "easy". \4

Obviously other things like CC or GPL Affero start putting more restrictions (Eg. non-commercial, or "can't use the software on a server without sharing") which push the envelope a bit. I'm sure others have tried to put restrictions eg. "can't use for military" into licenses \5

Whether those have ever been tested in court, I'm not sure.

I'm inclined to think that this is right. You try to undermine copyright through the legal GPL, and address other politics / morals through community practice, codes of conduct, culture rather than enforcing \6

That feels right to me ... but I admit maybe that's my libertarian bias showing through.

What I think certain is that law isn't a viable substitute for politics and community. If people want to be racist, a license in the blogging software can't / won't stop them \7

OTOH, I do think that platforms like Twitter and FB can and should enforce standards in their users, and chucking people off for dangerous disinformation or hate speech is fine. Just as a pub has the right to chuck out an aggressive drunken customer. \8

But that's based on a different principle. If you create a communal space, you have rights and responsibilities to keep that space healthy.

In summary, GPL is actively against imposing restrictions on particular uses. And I think that's fine. That's how it should be. \9

But that's because of the kind of thing the GPL is and software is.

People running platforms / communities can and should worry about the codes of practice, netiquette, policing abusive behaviour and the political fight against fascism.

That's where it should happen \10

Most importantly, EVERYTHING we face today was predicted in web.archive.org/web/2005061408… and everyone should go back, read, and think seriously about that. You cannot separate tech. from politics. \end

Stallman's RSS Feed

Sun May 14 10:16:51 UYT 2023
Battery manufacturers regulating supply lines themselves ) ... Sun May 14 10:01:53 UYT 2023
Putin's Zaporizhzhia card ) ... Sun May 14 10:01:52 UYT 2023
UK MPs urge minister to do more to free Hong Kongers ) ... Sun May 14 10:01:52 UYT 2023
Urgent: Medicare for All Act ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:11 UYT 2023
Urgent: Raise the debt ceiling ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:11 UYT 2023
Urgent: Sinclair local TV news content ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:10 UYT 2023
Urgent: Ban AI Use in Weapons Systems ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:10 UYT 2023
Rising gang violence unbearable, Pusher St., Copenhagen ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:10 UYT 2023
Spyware throttles Democracy, rights, EU ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:10 UYT 2023
Loyalty-politics is stifling, Hong Kong ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:09 UYT 2023
Battery mfgs regulating themselves ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:09 UYT 2023
Language machines cutting costs analyzing Afghan immigrants ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:09 UYT 2023
Book censorship, MO ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:09 UYT 2023
US lawmakers decry LNG infrastructure buildout plans ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:08 UYT 2023
Biomarker-based sleep-hygiene test ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:08 UYT 2023
Putins Zaporizhzhia card ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:08 UYT 2023
Private-jet subsidies ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:07 UYT 2023
Airline passenger-compensation rules ) ... Sun May 14 09:32:07 UYT 2023
UK MPs urge minister to do more to free Hongkongers ) ... Sat May 13 23:02:19 UYT 2023
The irony of too much “safety.” ) ... Sat May 13 23:02:18 UYT 2023
Santos and his 13-count indictment ) ... Sat May 13 23:02:18 UYT 2023
Billion-dollar extreme weather disasters ) ... Sat May 13 23:02:17 UYT 2023
Big Food Raking in Huge Profits ) ... Sat May 13 23:02:16 UYT 2023
Urgent: Revoke the NRA's tax exemption ) ... Sat May 13 17:46:54 UYT 2023
Urgent: Stop factory farms from polluting our rivers ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:03 UYT 2023
Urgent: List monarch butterflies as endangered ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:03 UYT 2023
Urgent: Make Bezos testify about Amazon's union-busting ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:02 UYT 2023
Urgent: Revoke the National Rifle Association's tax exemption ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:02 UYT 2023
Urgent: eliminate the subminimum wage ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:02 UYT 2023
History of technology as hoarding power ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:02 UYT 2023
(Satire) Pay judges an ethics bonus Payjudgesanethics_bonus)) ... Sat May 13 11:02:02 UYT 2023
Social utility of royal and presidential families ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:01 UYT 2023
"Link tax" would reward Sinclair ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:01 UYT 2023
GOP plans: nix New Deal ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:01 UYT 2023
Pseudo-police, UK ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:01 UYT 2023
The bully loses a lawsuit ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:01 UYT 2023
Ukrainian counteroffensive theory ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:01 UYT 2023
World's first public facial-recognition ban ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:01 UYT 2023
Wagner terrorist designation ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:00 UYT 2023
Feinstein returns to duty ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:00 UYT 2023
Supreme Court ethics: Crow's senators ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:00 UYT 2023
Coronation: protest group pre-arrested ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:00 UYT 2023
Ethnic violence, India ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:00 UYT 2023
GOP brinkmanship: SS, food, medical, education, climate ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:00 UYT 2023
US mercenaries' large role ) ... Sat May 13 11:02:00 UYT 2023
Legal drowsy driving limit: blood test ) ... Sat May 13 11:01:59 UYT 2023
Ceasefire bombing: 40 jets, 2 hr, 2 am ) ... Sat May 13 11:01:59 UYT 2023
Correction: Named days of the week for upcoming talks by Richard Stallman ) ... Thu May 11 21:31:44 UYT 2023
Correction: Upcoming talks by Richard Stallman, calendar ) ... Thu May 11 21:16:48 UYT 2023
The coronation pulled a screen across a desperate, polarized nation ) ... Sat May 13 11:16:46 UYT 2023
WhatsApp could disappear from UK over privacy concerns ) ... Thu May 11 01:01:58 UYT 2023
Why Native history is American history ) ... Thu May 11 01:01:57 UYT 2023
The coronation pulled a screen across a desperate, polarised nation ) ... Thu May 11 01:01:57 UYT 2023
There’s Still Time to Avoid Climate Catastrophe ) ... Thu May 11 01:01:57 UYT 2023
Workers to lose 300 million over grocery store merger ) ... Thu May 11 01:01:57 UYT 2023
Recent Day of the Worker now over ) ... Wed May 10 08:46:52 UYT 2023
Labour and Tories' anti-protest laws ) ... Tue May 09 17:16:45 UYT 2023
Right-wing fanatic drove car into immigrants ) ... Tue May 09 17:16:45 UYT 2023
Artists in Russia ) ... Tue May 09 17:16:45 UYT 2023
Old monetary policy vs new realities ) ... Tue May 09 04:16:56 UYT 2023
Big food profits vs world hunger ) ... Tue May 09 04:16:55 UYT 2023
(Satire) Mayor guts social services, is killed for it Mayorgutssocialservices,iskilledforit)) ... Tue May 09 04:01:45 UYT 2023
Big food profits vs the starvations ) ... Tue May 09 04:01:44 UYT 2023
Urgent: Plastic pusher, Whole Foods ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:54 UYT 2023
Old monetary policy vs new realies ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:54 UYT 2023
Unprecedented action on PFAS ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:54 UYT 2023
Non-destructive DNA extraction ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:53 UYT 2023
Technoscientific-innovation warning from the fine arts ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:53 UYT 2023
Big food profits vs starving ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:53 UYT 2023
Protester intolerance, UK ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:53 UYT 2023
PFAS testing: pesticides ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:53 UYT 2023
Social housing ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:53 UYT 2023
Invasive species: horses in AU ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:53 UYT 2023
Labour seconds bank expert into parliament ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:52 UYT 2023
Academic publishing vs profits ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:52 UYT 2023
Covid emergency officially over ) ... Tue May 09 03:46:52 UYT 2023
(satire) Lifesaving medication at U.S. border LifesavingmedicationatU.S._border)) ... Sun May 07 23:02:02 UYT 2023
New buildings in New York state ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:02 UYT 2023
Species threatened by Neonicotinoid Insecticides ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:02 UYT 2023
Execution of Richard Glossip canceled ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:02 UYT 2023
Putin told Clinton he might attack Ukraine ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:02 UYT 2023
Four "Proud Boys" convicted ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:01 UYT 2023
Bernie Sanders plan for $17 minimum wage ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:01 UYT 2023
Clarence Thomas' Grandnephew ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:01 UYT 2023
Media ignores nondisruptive protests ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:01 UYT 2023
Danger of bills that allow snooping ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:00 UYT 2023
Copyright lawsuits in music industry ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:00 UYT 2023
Florida might prohibit teaching critical race theory ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:00 UYT 2023
Voters blocked in UK ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:00 UYT 2023
Erdoğan law about "fake" news ) ... Sun May 07 23:02:00 UYT 2023
Upcoming talks: free software and digital injustice ) ... Sun May 07 08:47:54 UYT 2023
Urgent: Stop USPS privatization ) ... Sun May 07 08:47:54 UYT 2023
Supreme Court ethics, Ginni Thomas ) ... Sun May 07 08:47:53 UYT 2023
Mexico's US-deportee agreement ) ... Sun May 07 08:47:53 UYT 2023
US, Rx drug prices ) ... Sun May 07 08:47:52 UYT 2023
(Satire) Startups productivity Startupsproductivity)) ... Sun May 07 08:47:52 UYT 2023
Wrongful conviction, UK ) ... Sun May 07 08:47:51 UYT 2023
Climate news, CAN ) ... Sun May 07 08:47:51 UYT 2023
Chomsky on the AI news ) ... Sat May 06 09:31:45 UYT 2023
Resilience as luck and teamwork ) ... Sat May 06 09:31:45 UYT 2023
Dissident journalist kidnapped, now imprisoned ) ... Sat May 06 09:31:45 UYT 2023
Suicide sales from Canadian ) ... Sat May 06 09:31:45 UYT 2023
Starmer's Labour betrayals ) ... Sat May 06 09:31:44 UYT 2023
Big insurance lobby, FL ) ... Sat May 06 09:31:44 UYT 2023
Organized crimes law, EU ) ... Sat May 06 09:31:44 UYT 2023
Investigating Bolsonaro's tenure ) ... Sat May 06 09:31:42 UYT 2023
Study on raising minimum wage ) ... Fri May 05 23:31:50 UYT 2023
If you care about press freedom ) ... Fri May 05 23:31:49 UYT 2023
Right-wing Supreme Court on student loans ) ... Fri May 05 23:31:49 UYT 2023
Green investment funds ) ... Fri May 05 23:31:49 UYT 2023
Sexual pressure on women in the CIA ) ... Fri May 05 23:31:48 UYT 2023
ISDS clauses in trade treaties ) ... Fri May 05 23:31:48 UYT 2023
Michael Chong ) ... Fri May 05 23:31:48 UYT 2023
Call not to allow spy software ) ... Fri May 05 23:31:48 UYT 2023
Urgent: Repeal the 2002 authorization for the use of military force ) ... Fri May 05 07:31:48 UYT 2023
World Press Freedom yesterday ) ... Fri May 05 07:31:47 UYT 2023
Covid-19-related prison sentences ) ... Fri May 05 07:31:47 UYT 2023
Silencing society's freedom of belief ) ... Fri May 05 07:31:47 UYT 2023
Retirement-age protests, FR ) ... Fri May 05 07:31:47 UYT 2023
Activists arrested, GA ) ... Fri May 05 07:31:46 UYT 2023
Occupation-protests against fossil fuel ) ... Fri May 05 07:31:46 UYT 2023
Anti-monarchists, UK ) ... Fri May 05 07:31:45 UYT 2023
Urgent: Costco over-packaging small items ) ... Thu May 04 23:01:36 UYT 2023
Un-connection and in-authenticity ) ... Thu May 04 23:01:36 UYT 2023
May Day in RU ) ... Thu May 04 23:01:36 UYT 2023
States regulating PFAs ) ... Thu May 04 23:01:35 UYT 2023
Modern day hunting, ducks in AU ) ... Thu May 04 23:01:35 UYT 2023
Bytedance censorship tool ) ... Thu May 04 22:31:54 UYT 2023
Unprecedented giveaway to mining industry ) ... Thu May 04 22:31:54 UYT 2023
Mastodon to be easier to join ) ... Thu May 04 22:31:54 UYT 2023
Digital pet service ) ... Thu May 04 22:31:54 UYT 2023
Airbnb destroying communities ) ... Thu May 04 22:31:53 UYT 2023
Railroads gave paid sick leave to some unions ) ... Thu May 04 22:31:53 UYT 2023
Bill to extend debt ceiling ) ... Thu May 04 22:31:53 UYT 2023
Code of ethics on the Supreme Court ) ... Thu May 04 22:31:53 UYT 2023
Congress warned about EARN IT act ) ... Thu May 04 22:31:53 UYT 2023
Fishery lobbyists in EU delegation ) ... Thu May 04 22:31:53 UYT 2023
Fungal attacks on crops ) ... Thu May 04 22:31:53 UYT 2023
Climate myths by US beef industry ) ... Thu May 04 22:31:52 UYT 2023
Urgent: Divest in fossil fuels ) ... Thu May 04 00:16:34 UYT 2023
Urgent: Compensate drone-strike victims ) ... Thu May 04 00:16:34 UYT 2023
Democrats' election formula ) ... Thu May 04 00:16:34 UYT 2023
Nanoplastic particles in the brain ) ... Thu May 04 00:16:33 UYT 2023
Private jet footprint ) ... Thu May 04 00:16:33 UYT 2023
Brazilian mafia mining ) ... Thu May 04 00:16:33 UYT 2023
Death row, CA ) ... Thu May 04 00:16:33 UYT 2023
Politico's court power ) ... Thu May 04 00:16:33 UYT 2023
Shelter help, UK ) ... Thu May 04 00:16:32 UYT 2023
Urgent: Call on Feinstein to resign ) ... Wed May 03 08:46:36 UYT 2023
Urgent: Stop collecting abortion seeker data ) ... Wed May 03 08:46:36 UYT 2023
Urgent: Stop paying extra to carry Faux News ) ... Wed May 03 08:46:36 UYT 2023
Ban on symbols, salute, AU ) ... Wed May 03 08:46:36 UYT 2023
Radical right paranoid style world ) ... Wed May 03 08:46:36 UYT 2023
Thousands will rage, UK ) ... Wed May 03 08:46:36 UYT 2023
Policy changes favor the rich, EU ) ... Wed May 03 08:46:35 UYT 2023
Deregulation worsened "too big to fail", banks ) ... Wed May 03 08:46:35 UYT 2023
Urgent: a business-supremacy treaty to block ) ... Tue May 02 09:01:51 UYT 2023
Urgent: Walgreens not dispensing abortion pills ) ... Tue May 02 09:01:51 UYT 2023
Urgent: Censorship in FL ) ... Tue May 02 09:01:51 UYT 2023
Urgent: Trader Joe's union ) ... Tue May 02 09:01:50 UYT 2023
Non-violent protester, years of prison, UK ) ... Tue May 02 09:01:50 UYT 2023
Equal Rights Amendment blocked ) ... Tue May 02 09:01:50 UYT 2023
Inequality fixes: patience low ) ... Tue May 02 09:01:50 UYT 2023
Musician wiggle room ) ... Tue May 02 09:01:49 UYT 2023
Protesters, irascible thugs, UK ) ... Tue May 02 09:01:49 UYT 2023
Protesters block White House ) ... Tue May 02 09:01:49 UYT 2023
Sudan's fighting, the interests involved ) ... Tue May 02 09:01:48 UYT 2023
Republicans' traps in budget negotiations ) ... Mon May 01 11:01:36 UYT 2023
Protesters, beatings, NY ) ... Mon May 01 10:46:40 UYT 2023
Gerrymandering legalized, NC ) ... Mon May 01 10:46:40 UYT 2023
A young NY Mayor on progressive policy ) ... Mon May 01 10:46:40 UYT 2023
Wikipedia warns ) ... Mon May 01 10:46:40 UYT 2023
Dulles politicos wrote the book ) ... Mon May 01 10:46:39 UYT 2023
Homelessness: Finland vs Canada ) ... Mon May 01 10:46:39 UYT 2023
Republicans' pitfalls in budget negotiations ) ... Mon May 01 07:16:31 UYT 2023
Republican pitfalls in budget negotiations ) ... Sun Apr 30 22:18:19 UYT 2023
UN reaches judgement against US et al ) ... Sun Apr 30 22:18:18 UYT 2023
GOP misusing "insurrection" ) ... Sun Apr 30 22:18:18 UYT 2023
Garment workers status ) ... Sun Apr 30 22:18:18 UYT 2023
China as peacemaker ) ... Sun Apr 30 22:18:18 UYT 2023
Mariupol ) ... Sun Apr 30 22:18:18 UYT 2023
Invasive species vs humans ) ... Sun Apr 30 22:18:18 UYT 2023
Invasive species V humans ) ... Sun Apr 30 09:03:27 UYT 2023
Green energy, AU ) ... Sun Apr 30 09:03:27 UYT 2023
Nursing Home ownership, US ) ... Sun Apr 30 09:03:27 UYT 2023
(Satire) Great Pacific Garbage Patch GreatPacificGarbagePatch)) ... Sun Apr 30 09:03:26 UYT 2023
Republican counter-offensive against voter registration, FL ) ... Sun Apr 30 09:03:26 UYT 2023
GOP hypocrisy: "weaponization of govt" ) ... Sun Apr 30 08:03:10 UYT 2023
GOP hypocrisy: "judicial activism" ) ... Sun Apr 30 08:03:09 UYT 2023
SpaceX Starship's environmental damage ) ... Sun Apr 30 08:03:09 UYT 2023
Using AI to launch nukes ) ... Sun Apr 30 07:48:22 UYT 2023
GOP hypocracy: "weaponization of govt" ) ... Sun Apr 30 07:48:21 UYT 2023
Momentum in a death penalty case, OK ) ... Sun Apr 30 07:48:21 UYT 2023
Donations to the US Chamber of Commerce, an analysis ) ... Sun Apr 30 07:48:21 UYT 2023
New charges against Alexei Navalny ) ... Sun Apr 30 07:48:21 UYT 2023
Medically necessary abortions in OK ) ... Sun Apr 30 07:48:20 UYT 2023
GOP hypocracy: "judicial activism" ) ... Sun Apr 30 07:48:20 UYT 2023
GOP fuel: anxiety ) ... Sun Apr 30 07:48:20 UYT 2023
"News" as bias and lies currying favor for a harmful foreign empire ) ... Sun Apr 30 07:48:20 UYT 2023